Compliance with laws and regulations is a crucial factor that needs to be a priority for companies to ensure that businesses are run in accordance with existing regulations.
This is important to avoid the risk of legal sanctions that can disrupt the continuity of the company's operations.
There are various programs that can help improve corporate compliance with the law, one of which is implementing audit periodically.
This article covers the definition of a compliance audit, how it differs from financial and operational audits, its benefits, types, implementation steps, reports, and examples.
What Is the Meaning of Compliance Audit?
A compliance audit is an evaluation process to ensure that an organization, company, or individual complies with applicable rules, policies, standards, and regulations. It is also known as a compliance audit or audit ketaatan.
The purpose of a compliance audit is to assess the extent to which the company's activities, procedures, and policies are in compliance with the rules that have been established by the authorities or the company's internal standards.
Compliance audit are often conducted in various fields, such as finance, law, information security, or the environment, and help identify potential risks or violations and provide recommendations for improvement to enhance future compliance.
So, compliance audit is an evaluation of the extent to which a company meets the rules and policies that apply in its industry and region. It can be carried out by internal auditors, external auditors, or regulators, depending on the audit objective. In a financial statement audit, the external auditor also considers the entity's compliance with laws and regulations under Auditing Standard (SA) 250.
How Does a Compliance Audit Differ from Financial and Operational Audits?
| Aspect | Compliance Audit | Financial Audit | Operational Audit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Main question | Are rules and policies being followed? | Are the financial statements fairly presented? | Are activities running effectively and efficiently? |
| Criteria | Regulations, contracts, standards, and internal policies | Applicable accounting standards | Targets, procedures, and good practices |
| Results | List of noncompliance items and recommendations | Auditor's opinion | Findings and process improvement recommendations |
In one engagement, all three can run at the same time. The types and examples of operational audits are discussed in the article operational audit.
What Are the Benefits of Compliance Audit?
Compliance audit has a very important role because it helps in determining the level of company compliance with applicable rules, regulations, and standards. Here are some of its benefits, among others:
1. Reducing Legal Risks
The first benefit of compliance audit is that conducting them regularly allows companies to ensure that they comply with all relevant government regulations, thereby reducing the likelihood of fines or penalties and ensuring future compliance.
2. Identify Improvement Opportunities
The second benefit of a compliance audit is that it can identify systems or processes that are not in line with market developments and needs. Auditor provide recommendations that can help organizations implement more efficient systems and processes.
3. Increase Security Measures
Other benefits compliance audit it has the function of checking whether the company has met the established safety requirements, as well as providing directions for creating a safer working environment.
What Are the Types of Compliance Audit?
Compliance audits can be distinguished by the source of the rules and who carries them out. Here are five common types:
1. Legal Compliance Audit
Types compliance audit the first is to have the objective of evaluating the company's compliance with applicable legal provisions by examining various legal aspects related to business activities, such as labor law, tax law, environmental law, as well as contract law.
2. Internal Compliance Audit
Types compliance audit the second can be done to ensure that the company complies with the established internal policies, procedures and guidelines, through a comparison between internal policies and concrete actions carried out by the entity, as well as evaluating the existing internal control system.
3. External Compliance Audit
The next type of compliance audit is external compliance audit, implemented by external parties who have the independence and expertise to assess the company's compliance with external requirements. This examination includes the extent to which the company complies with the relevant external regulations in a particular industry or sector.
4. Industry Standard Compliance Audit
The next type of compliance audit it has the purpose of ensuring that the company carries out its operational activities in accordance with the standards of quality, safety, security or other requirements applicable in the industry.
5. Financial Process Compliance Audit
The last type of compliance audit is in financial process management, which involves an in-depth examination of various regulations governing business financial management, including tax regulations, capital market regulations, and annual reporting requirements.
What Are the Steps in a Compliance Audit?
- Set the scope and criteria. Determine the rules, contracts, or policies to be tested, along with the units and period.
- Map the obligations. List the compliance obligations along with the responsible process owners.
- Assess the risk of noncompliance. Prioritize obligations with heavy sanctions or frequent violations. How to do this is discussed in the article risk assessment.
- Test compliance. Examine samples of documents, transactions, and field practices against the criteria.
- Report the findings. Describe the condition, criteria, cause, effect, and recommendation.
- Monitor follow-up. Make sure improvements are completed on schedule, then retest if needed. The practice is covered in the article follow-up on internal audit findings.
What Is a Compliance Audit Report?
A compliance audit report is an official document prepared by the auditor as the final output of the compliance audit process. This document serves as written evidence of the company's compliance level and the basis for management to take corrective action. In general, this report contains:
- Executive summary: a short overview of the audit objective, scope, and conclusion.
- Areas and period examined: the parts of the organization and the time period covered by the audit.
- Findings and compliance level: a list of nonconformities found along with their severity.
- Repair recommendations: concrete steps recommended to close compliance gaps.
- Follow-up deadline: a schedule for implementing improvements and re-auditing if needed.
The format and level of detail of the report can vary depending on the regulator or standard used as a reference, but the five components above are almost always present in a good compliance audit report.
What Are Examples of Compliance Audit?
Example of compliance audit can be found in various sectors, such as finance, health, technology, and the environment. Here are some examples compliance audit are among others:
1. Financial Compliance Audit
The first example of a compliance audit is in the field of finance. A company undergoes a compliance audit of applicable accounting standards and tax regulations.
The Auditor will check whether the financial statements have been prepared in accordance with applicable accounting standards (e.g. IFRS or GAAP) and whether the company complies with the tax regulations established by the tax authorities.
2. Legal Compliance Audit
The second example is in the legal field. For instance, a pharmaceutical company undergoes an audit to ensure its products comply with health and drug regulations, such as those set by the Indonesian Food and Drug Authority (BPOM) or the Food and Drug Administration (FDA).
3. Environmental Compliance Audit
Other examples compliance audit is on the environment. A manufacturing plant is audited to ensure that its production processes comply with environmental regulations, such as waste management, gas emissions, and the use of hazardous chemicals in accordance with national or international environmental standards.
4. Data Security Compliance Audit (Data Privacy Audit)
Other examples compliance audit is in data security. A technology company that manages users' personal data undergoes an audit to ensure compliance with Law Number 27 of 2022 on Personal Data Protection (PDP Law), as well as the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) if it serves users in the European Union. A guide is available in the article PDP Law compliance audit.
The Auditor will check whether the company has protected personal data in accordance with legal requirements, such as clear privacy notices and secure management of user data.
5. Labor Compliance Audit
Another example of a compliance audit is in employment. The company undergoes compliance audits to ensure that labor policies, such as minimum wage, working hours, Occupational Safety, and non-discrimination, comply with applicable labor laws in the country.
Compliance audits help organizations detect potential violations and risks and maintain a company's reputation and integrity in the eyes of regulators and the public.
FAQ About Compliance Audits
What is a compliance audit?
A compliance audit or compliance audit, also known in Indonesian as audit ketaatan, is an evaluation process to ensure that an organization, company, or individual complies with applicable rules, policies, standards, and regulations. It can be carried out by internal auditors, external auditors, or regulators.
What is a compliance audit report?
A compliance audit report is an official document resulting from the audit that contains an executive summary, the areas and period examined, findings along with their compliance level, improvement recommendations, and a follow-up deadline. This document becomes the basis for management to take corrective action.
What is the purpose of a compliance audit?
To assess the extent to which the company's activities, procedures, and policies comply with rules set by the authorities and with internal company standards, while identifying potential risks or violations along with improvement recommendations.
What are the benefits of a compliance audit for companies?
Three benefits: reducing legal risk to avoid fines or penalties, identifying improvement opportunities in systems and processes no longer suited to market needs, and strengthening security measures for a safer work environment.
What are the types of compliance audits?
Five types: legal compliance audits, internal compliance audit, external compliance audit, industry standard compliance audits, and financial process compliance audits.
What is the difference between a internal and external compliance audit?
Internal compliance audit ensures the company adheres to its own internal policies, procedures, and guidelines while evaluating the internal control system. External compliance audit is carried out by an independent external party to assess compliance with the external regulations applicable in that industry or sector.
What are the steps in a compliance audit?
Six steps: set the scope and criteria, map the compliance obligations, assess the risk of noncompliance, test samples of documents and practices, report findings with recommendations, then monitor the follow-up until it is complete.
What is the difference between a compliance audit and a financial audit?
A compliance audit assesses whether rules and policies are followed, and its result is a list of noncompliance items and recommendations. A financial audit assesses whether the financial statements are fairly presented under accounting standards, and its result is the auditor's opinion.
What are examples of compliance audits in practice?
Financial compliance audits against accounting standards and tax rules, legal compliance audits such as pharmaceutical products against BPOM or FDA regulations, environmental compliance audits over waste management and gas emissions, data security audits against privacy regulations such as GDPR, and labor audits concerning minimum wage, working hours, and workplace safety.
Read also, audit applications for cross-sector compliance:
- Internal Quality Audit (AMI) Application: A Guide for Higher Education Institutions
- Retail Audit Software: A Guide to Features, Benefits, and How to Choose
- Restaurant Audit Application to Maintain Operational Standards and Food Safety
- Construction Project Audit Application: A Complete Guide
- Insurance Company Audit Application: A Complete Guide
Conclusion
In conclusion, a compliance audit is an important evaluation process to ensure that a company or organization complies with applicable regulations, policies, and standards, both internally and externally. The main benefits of compliance audits include the reduction of legal risks, the improvement of business processes, and the creation of a safer work environment.
These audits not only help identify legal risks and violations, but also provide remedial opportunities that can improve work efficiency and safety.
There are various types of compliance audits, all of which have an important role in maintaining the integrity and continuity of the company's operations in accordance with applicable regulations.
Audithink is internal audit management software with six main features: risk assessment, audit planning, work program templates, notifications, follow-up monitoring, and automated reports. The follow-up monitoring feature helps ensure compliance audit recommendations are completed on schedule.
Schedule a demo to see how it works.
